Just for the record I don’t know a lot about guns or hunting. This is just a thought experiment based on my experience with a hunting video game but now I’m curious if the concept could maybe be actually good.

So in “theHunter: Call of the Wild” there’s a revolver modeled after the Taurus Judge that’s chambered for .45 Colt as well as .410. It’s pretty interesting but not all that useful in practice since it lacks range and power. To my knowledge the actual Judge isn’t marketed as a hunting sidearm but rather as a self defense weapon.

So I got thinking how it could be improved upon and came up with what you see in the sketch. Kind of a bullpup design to give you more barrel length while retaining pocketability, weaver rail for sights, and a grip for better accuracy.

Would this just break and burn your hands or is there a way this could work? And would it even be an improvement? One drawback I’m seeing is that you couldn’t fire multiple shots in single action unless you fan it cowboy-style but I’m not sure how relevant that is for irl hunting. I feel like as long as the trigger isn’t impossibly hard to pull double action with birdshot could be viable for duck hunting and in most other scenarios you’d probably take one shot at a time anyway.

So yeah, thoughts?

  • Fondots@lemmy.world
    3·
    4 days ago

    Looks like other have covered the issues with a bull pup revolver well enough, don’t think I have anything to add there

    Handgun hunting is a thing, I don’t really understand the appeal myself, but AFAIK .45 colt is a reasonably popular choice in that field, and with the right ammo and a reasonably short range can even be used for bear

    .410 out of a revolver is probably pretty useless for hunting though. Since the barrel is rifled, that shot is going to start spinning and make it spread out a lot faster and farther than out of a smoothbore barrel, you don’t have that much shot in a .410 shell to begin with so there’s gonna be a whole lot of space between them when it gets to your target. You’re gonna need a big target at close range and a lot of luck to make sure that shot is hitting somewhere vital, and at that point you’re probably better off trying to hit it with a regular rifle or handgun.