This community likes to remind everyone that no communist country was allowed to just be communists in peace. So there was no “proper” communist country.
My point isn’t “socialism in real life is bad, but was only forced that way because of imperialists.” My point is that I support socialism, including the development of state power required to protect socialism from sabateurs and imperialists, knowing that no implementation of state power has ever been free of sin. I acknowledge the necessity of protecting socialism, and the immense gains made by these systems for their working classes.
The fact of the matter is that imperialist countries do exist, and any socialist country must therefore develop means to protect itself. This is an internally driven necessity from solving the contradiction between imperialist and subjugated countries. It isn’t something imposed from the outside, but the inside reacting to conditions it is in.
No? It seems like you’re deliberately refusing to see the point. Socialism is good and defending itself is necessary. You’re taking a mechanistic approach.
deleted by creator
I was arguing against this point in particular.
deleted by creator
They were absolutely proper, “purity” in constructing socialism is something liberals obsess over.
deleted by creator
My point isn’t “socialism in real life is bad, but was only forced that way because of imperialists.” My point is that I support socialism, including the development of state power required to protect socialism from sabateurs and imperialists, knowing that no implementation of state power has ever been free of sin. I acknowledge the necessity of protecting socialism, and the immense gains made by these systems for their working classes.
The fact of the matter is that imperialist countries do exist, and any socialist country must therefore develop means to protect itself. This is an internally driven necessity from solving the contradiction between imperialist and subjugated countries. It isn’t something imposed from the outside, but the inside reacting to conditions it is in.
deleted by creator
No? It seems like you’re deliberately refusing to see the point. Socialism is good and defending itself is necessary. You’re taking a mechanistic approach.
deleted by creator